How Is Income Imputed When Your Spouse Owns a Business?

By Millad Ossudallah, Family Lawyer, Vancouver 

In Canada, the Federal Child Support Guidelines (the “Guidelines”) set out how child support is calculated. One of the most important parts of that calculation is determining each spouse’s income. Generally, the starting point is the total income reported on their personal tax return, and for most people this provides a fairly clear picture. However, things can become more complicated when a spouse owns a business or is a shareholder, director or officer of a corporation.

In these situations, the income reported on a spouse’s personal tax return may not reflect all the money available to them. For example, they may receive benefits through that business, such as the use of a company vehicle, phone or food allowance. They may also have access to money through shareholder loans or leave income within the corporation rather than paying it out personally. These arrangements can mean that the spouse has access to more financial resources than their tax return alone would suggest. 

When a personal tax return does not provide a complete picture, the court can look at the spouse’s corporate finances and other financial information to determine what income is actually available for support. This may result in additional income being attributed, or “imputed,” to the spouse. In this blog, we look at when courts may impute income to a spouse who owns a company or has an interest in a corporation and some of the factors they consider when determining that income.


The Starting Point: Financial Disclosure

When child support discussions begin, the first step is usually the exchange of financial disclosure, where each spouse shares their financial information. This includes each party’s income documents, such as tax returns, notices of assessment and pay stubs, as well as receipts and records for any child-related expenses. However, if a parent is a shareholder, director, or officer of a corporation, these standard documents may not provide a complete picture of the funds available for support. In these instances, a deeper analysis of the business’ financial records may be necessary. Some additional documents that may be requested include:

  1. Company Search and Share Certificates - A company search can identify the corporation’s directors, while share certificates provide evidence of share ownership. This matters because a person’s role and ownership interest in the corporation can affect the financial information available to them and the level of control they have over corporate finances.
  2. Financial Statements and Corporate Tax Returns - These documents provide a breakdown of the company’s revenue, expenses, assets, and liabilities. This information can help identify retained earnings, which are profits that remain within the corporation rather than being distributed to its owners. Depending on when the company was incorporated, you should attempt to obtain financial statements for the past three years to determine patterns in the company’s income and expenses. After these records have been reviewed, additional documents may be needed to understand how money moved through the corporation and whether funds were paid or made available to its shareholders or directors.
  3. Balance Sheet - This financial record provides a clear picture of the resources the company controls, including cash, inventory, liabilities and shareholder loans.
  4. General Ledger - These records detail each business transaction, including the date and amounts credited or debited, helping to trace how funds are moved and managed within the company.
  5. Bank Statements - These statements trace the flow of money in and out of the corporation and can help identify income that may not otherwise be disclosed.

Why Might Reported Income Not Tell the Whole Story?

A spouse who is a shareholder, director, or officer of a corporation may be able to delay reporting income or hide money within the corporation, which can affect the amount of income available for support. To get a clearer picture, the court may consider factors such as a parent’s lifestyle, monthly living expenses, assets, investments, and the range of income earned during the relationship. 


What are “retained earnings”?

Retained earnings refer to profits that have been generated but not yet distributed to company owners. There are several reasons why a company might choose to retain its earnings, such as maintaining a minimum balance for financial security or covering operating costs. For example, an incorporated restaurant may need to keep money in the company to pay employees or purchase supplies. However, it is also possible that a spouse could intentionally leave these funds in the company to lower their declared income, thereby reducing their support payments. In such cases, it is the responsibility of the payor spouse (i.e., the spouse paying support) to prove to the court that there are valid business reasons for not paying out these earnings. 


What Makes a Business Expense Reasonable or Unreasonable?

Although there are legitimate business expenses that can be reasonably deducted for income tax purposes, there are some expenses that provide a personal benefit, such as meals and entertainment, cellphones, or company vehicles.

Once the corporate financial statements are available, the expenses and deductions can be reviewed. The court has broad discretion to impute income to the payor spouse if it determines that business expenses have been unreasonably deducted. An expense may be allowed for income tax purposes but still be excluded when calculating income for support. The following are examples of business expenses the court may review:

  1. Advertising and promotion.
  2. Meals and entertainment.
  3. Office and miscellaneous.
  4. Salaries and related benefits.
  5. Supplies.
  6. Travel. 
You can ask for more financial records to review the corporation’s business expenses. These may include receipts for meals and entertainment or travel documents showing whether a trip was for business purposes. The expenses of a company must be reasonable and legitimate for business purposes, or a court could impute those amounts as income when calculating support. 

The person asking the court to impute income to the payor spouse must show there is a reasonable basis for doing so. When assessing income, the court can take a common-sense approach to reviewing financial information and expenses. If the payor spouse provides no evidence to justify certain expenses, the court may add those amounts back to their income when calculating support.


What Are Shareholder Loans?

A corporation’s financial statement may have an amount “due to shareholder,” meaning the corporation owes money to the shareholder, or “due from shareholder”, meaning the shareholder owes money to the corporation. 

The court may consider whether some or all of a shareholder loan repayment should be treated as income when calculating support. Whether these amounts are treated as income will depend on the facts of the case. For example, imputing income may be justified if a shareholder loan far exceeds a payor’s employment income or the payor spouse can withdraw funds from the company through shareholder loan repayments. These circumstances may give grounds for an imputation of income. In the end, the payor spouse must prove that the shareholder loans were used to keep the company running.


How is income imputed?

When the income reported on a spouse’s personal tax return does not fairly reflect all the money available to them for child support, the court may look more closely at the corporation’s pre-tax income. This can provide a starting point for determining the spouse’s income for support purposes.

In reviewing the corporate finances, the court may also add certain amounts back to the spouse’s income. For example, the court may review expenses such as advertising, amortization, management fees or office expenses to determine whether they are reasonable business expenses or should instead be treated as income available to the spouse.

This analysis may be different at an interim court application, where the court is working with a more limited evidentiary record.

Where the corporate finances are complex, an expert may also be appointed to prepare a Guideline income analysis. The expert can review the corporate finances and provide different scenarios for determining the spouse’s income for support purposes. If there is no Guideline income report available, the court may order the parties to appoint an expert to determine the spouse’s income.


Final Steps to Take if the Numbers Don’t Add Up

After reviewing the documents and disclosure from the payor spouse, there may still be discrepancies or concerns with the corporation’s finances. In that case, you may be able to question the spouse through an examination for discovery, a pre-trial process where they answer questions under oath. This can help you better understand the company’s finances and clarify any gaps or inconsistencies in the disclosure.

If a company’s finances are particularly complex, it may be helpful to hire an expert to complete a thorough analysis of the spouse’s income before bringing a court application to impute income. The expert can prepare a report, often referred to as a guideline income analysis, outlining different ways the spouse’s income could be calculated for support purposes. A report may also be obtained before trial to assist the judge in determining whether, and how much, income should be imputed to the payor spouse. This analysis can be costly, averaging $7,000 to $10,000. As a less costly alternative, you can propose using the corporation’s pre-tax income shown in its financial statements as the payor spouse’s guideline income.

When your spouse earns income through a corporation, their tax return may not tell the whole story. The court can look at the company’s pre-tax income, retained earnings, business expenses, and shareholder loans to determine how much income should be used to calculate support. Requesting the right financial documents and knowing what to look for can make a difference in how child support is calculated.

At Crossroads Law, our dedicated team of family lawyers is experienced in helping clients navigate child support cases involving corporate income, from requesting financial records to challenging income calculations in court. Book your free 20-minute consultation online or by phone.

The information contained in this blog is not legal advice and should not be construed as legal advice on any subject. The information provided in this blog is for informational purposes only.